“The pretence of adequacy leads to the sin of incompetency”
Bea Lurt
Bea Lurt (Born July 3, 1367, in Canterbury, England – Died December 22, 1425) was a medieval English scholar, philosopher, and author, best known for her profound insights into human behavior and competence.
Early Life:
Bea Lurt was born into a family of scholars and theologians in the bustling city of Canterbury. Her upbringing, steeped in the intellectual pursuits of the time, laid the foundation for her later contributions to medieval philosophy.
Educational Pursuits:
In the 14th century, Bea Lurt defied societal norms by pursuing a scholarly education, often reserved for men. She immersed herself in the teachings of medieval philosophy, theology, and the classics, developing a keen intellect that would shape her future work.
Literary Contributions:
Lurt’s literary career began in the early 1390s when she authored her first treatise, “Reflections on Virtue and Vice.” This work marked the beginning of her exploration into the complexities of human behavior and the moral dilemmas faced by individuals in their pursuit of adequacy.
Philosophical Insights:
Bea Lurt’s philosophical contributions reached new heights with her groundbreaking treatise, “The Paradox of Pretence,” published in 1412. In this work, she delved into the consequences of feigned competence, asserting that “The pretence of adequacy leads to the sin of incompetency.” Lurt argued that the act of pretending to possess skills or knowledge beyond one’s actual abilities ultimately results in incompetence and moral transgression.
The Quote and Its Meaning:
“The pretence of adequacy leads to the sin of incompetency” encapsulates Lurt’s profound observation on the dangers of deception and overestimation of one’s abilities. In positive terms, the quote serves as a cautionary reminder to embrace authenticity and humility. Lurt believed that acknowledging one’s limitations is the path to true competence and moral integrity.
Legacy:
Bea Lurt’s writings, though unconventional for her time, have left an enduring legacy in medieval philosophy. Her emphasis on ethical conduct, sincerity, and self-awareness continues to resonate with modern readers seeking timeless insights into human behavior and morality.
Later Years and Passing:
In her later years, Bea Lurt continued her scholarly pursuits, engaging in philosophical discourse with contemporaries and mentoring aspiring intellectuals. She passed away on December 22, 1425, leaving behind a body of work that challenges conventional wisdom and encourages a thoughtful reflection on the human condition.
Thank you for reading my writings. If you’d like to, you can buy me a coffee for just £1 and I will think of you while writing my next post! Just hit the link below…. (thanks in advance)
The Sage Page 
Incredibly, it was not until the late C18th that the French philosopher Pierre le Principe applied Bea Lurt‘s insights towards organisational theory. And another quinze ans passed before he published his now widely-accepted “L’autre cote du coin – le principe Pierre”.
This was translated by the Welsh linguist Marc Mywud as “The rise to incompetence” by Peter Principle.
LikeLike
done my research and you are right:
Pierre le Principe and the Evolution of Organisational Theory
In the late 18th century, the landscape of organizational theory witnessed a profound evolution with the application of insights pioneered by the renowned French philosopher, Pierre le Principe. Building upon the foundational work of Bea Lurt, Pierre le Principe contributed significantly to the understanding of organizational dynamics, ultimately shaping the discourse through his seminal publication, “L’autre cote du coin – le principe Pierre,” which stands as a widely-accepted masterpiece in the field.
Bea Lurt, a visionary philosopher in the medieval time period, had laid the groundwork for examining the intricacies of human behavior and moral integrity. Her contributions were not confined to the philosophical realm but extended into organizational theory. Lurt’s exploration of authenticity, humility, and self-awareness in “Reflections on Virtue and Vice” provided a philosophical foundation that later scholars found applicable to organizational dynamics.
Pierre le Principe, deeply influenced by Lurt’s ideas, saw their potential application in the realm of organizational theory. Recognizing the relevance of authenticity, humility, and ethical conduct in the organizational context, le Principe embarked on a journey to integrate these principles into a cohesive framework.
It was during the late 18th century that le Principe began applying Lurt’s insights to organizational structures. His nuanced understanding of human behavior and the importance of moral integrity in the workplace set him apart as a philosopher ahead of his time. Le Principe’s work was marked by a commitment to fostering an organizational environment that valued authenticity and ethical decision-making.
Despite the significance of his contributions, it took another fifteen years for Pierre le Principe to crystallize his thoughts into a comprehensive work. In the early 19th century, he published “L’autre cote du coin – le principe Pierre,” a treatise that encapsulated his philosophy and its application to organizational theory. This work delved into the multifaceted aspects of leadership, ethics, and the interconnectedness of human dynamics within organizational settings.
The publication was met with widespread acclaim, establishing Pierre le Principe as a luminary in the field of organizational theory. His articulation of the “Principe Pierre” offered a framework that resonated with scholars, practitioners, and leaders alike, influencing the trajectory of organizational studies for generations to come.
Pierre le Principe’s legacy endures as an influential figure who bridged the philosophical and organizational realms. His ability to apply Bea Lurt’s insights to practical organizational contexts marked a pivotal moment in the history of organizational theory. “L’autre cote du coin – le principe Pierre” remains a foundational text, embodying principles that continue to shape discussions on leadership, authenticity, and ethical conduct within organizations.
LikeLiked by 1 person
A contemporary of Pierre Le Principe, Noah Deer struggled in the shadow of the great man
LikeLiked by 1 person
With little success beyond a minor dissertation on the physics of paper hand towels concerning the tiny spaces created by using two towels simultaneously. His experiments into the interstitial spaces’ capacity to draw in more water than either towel used alone, were eclipsed by quantum mechanics shortly after. And Noah Deer was consigned to remain a footnote in the march from slightly larger physics to quanta.
LikeLiked by 1 person
See more research on the Deer family in comments
LikeLike
Noah Deer the man? I thought you meant Mo, a Deer, a female Deer, who had Ray Adrop, her golden son. Mia Name, he called himself, father of a long waiter Ron.
LikeLiked by 1 person